by Kelso » Thu Jan 19, 2012 9:11 pm
Oh, Geez. SOPA/PIPA I'm definitely against, and I'm not a huge fan of the current DMCA laws either, but if all this SOPA talk wasn't happening right now I still wouldn't have been that surprised by MU going down. The extent of it is surprising of course, but so were the takedowns of Napster, Limewire, Suprnova, etc. PB is probably the only one that really weathered their respective storm well. The fact that the MU bust was coordinated from the US but is mostly taking place outside the US is a... little disconcerting, but presumably this has been coordinated with the local law enforcement and in countries where those same copyright laws extend to. Still, I don't really file it all in the "good sign" category.
While it was one of the bigger and better file sharing sites, MU is hardly the only one. Others will now be jumping to take its place and feed on its sweet, sweet user base.
True, MU was rife with copyright infringement, there's no denying that, but there were many people and businesses that also used it for legitimate file storage of their own intellectual property. That's all gone too as a casualty. It's like a building that the police know has criminals in it, but they're all mixed in with normal citizens. Instead of sorting it out properly, they just set the building on fire, arrest everyone that runs out, and deal with it afterwards. As for all the private property of the innocents, well that's just collateral damage. I suppose I could have replaced "building" with "country", but that might be getting too political.
As for the Anon response, again I'm not surprised and a part of me gets their angry attack, but on the other hand it feels like it's more likely to harm what was gained in the peaceful blackout SOPA protests. Not to mention, never mind piracy laws, I'm pretty sure attacks on websites of the FBI and the like is considered a treasonable offense domestically and a "terrorist" act from a foreign source. That kind of stuff actually could land someone in Guantanamo under current laws.
